Is prune juice bad for gout?
Dr. Martin's answer is yes, and it is not about prunes. To be plain about it, he has never discussed prune juice and gout together on the show. What he has done, on episode after episode, is give one rule for gout that covers every juice in the store. This is how he put it on episode 1286.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 1286So if you know anybody that's got gout, stop drinking soda, stop drinking juices of any kind, no more, nada, no more. It's amazing what happens.
Juices of any kind includes prune juice. Many women over 60 keep a bottle in the fridge for regularity and think of it as a healthy drink. On his reasoning, if gout or high uric acid is part of your picture, that glass is working against you.
He said the same thing years earlier, describing what he told patients in his office whose uric acid would not come down.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 569One of the things I tell them to do is to cut their sugars, read every label, read every label, cut their fruits down to almost nothing, certainly don't drink any fruit drinks, okay?
Prunes are low in purines. Why is that not enough?
Most of what you will read about prune juice and gout starts and stops with purines. Prunes are low in purines, so the usual advice is that prune juice is fine. Dr. Martin does not accept the starting point. In his teaching, purines are not the main source of uric acid. Fructose is.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 566So remember what I said: uric acid is a by-product of fructose. Not purines, fructose.
That is why he has spent years pushing back on the red meat advice for gout. Steak has next to no sugar. Juice is low in purines and high in fructose. On his view, the juice is the bigger problem of the two. He covers the meat side in full in does red meat cause gout.
So a low purine count does not make prune juice safe in his book. The question he asks is how much fructose is in the glass, and with any fruit juice the answer is a lot.
Is natural, unsweetened juice any better?
This is where people push back. Prune juice is fruit. It is not soda. Surely natural sugar is different? Dr. Martin's answer is that, for uric acid, it is not.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 566But gout is uric acid, and uric acid is a by-product of fructose whether it'd be a grape or whether it'd be a soda. It doesn't matter as far as uric acid goes.
He does not mean soda and fruit are equal in every way. He calls fruit God's candies, and he has nothing good to say about soda. But on the one question of uric acid, the source of the fructose does not change the result. A glass of 100% juice with no sugar added still carries all the fruit sugar.
He made the point about the most popular juice of all, orange juice, and the brand people hold up as the healthy one.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 569I don't care what kind of fruit juice it is. It is terrible for you.
Why drinking fruit is worse than eating it
The word Dr. Martin keeps coming back to is drinking. In his view the form matters as much as the food. Eating a piece of fruit and drinking a glass of its juice are not the same thing to him.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 1286The biggest, biggest thing is when I get people to get off drinking sugar, drinking it, the fructose, it's the worst thing you can do is drink sugar.
On episode 1068 he brought this back to oranges, in a show about uric acid, gout and the kidneys.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 1068Don't ever drink Tropicana or orange juice. God wanted you to eat oranges, not drink it.
Swap oranges for plums and the logic is the same. A prune is a dried plum. Prune juice is the sugar of those dried plums in liquid form.
What about whole prunes?
He has not talked about prunes and gout together. Prunes did come up once, when a listener asked about them as a source of the mineral boron. He told her not to eat them and pointed straight at how sweet they are, with lots of sugar. That was a question about boron, not gout, but it shows how he sees prunes: as a sugar food.
For people with gout he was strict about whole fruit too. He counted it toward a daily sugar limit, and some fruits went off the list altogether.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 569If you're a person or you know someone in your family or loved one that gets gout, they can't have a banana.
So on his reasoning, a few prunes are not a free pass either. If you have gout, the fruit he leans toward is a few berries, and even those in small amounts.
What actually drives gout, in his view
Dr. Martin takes it one step further back than fructose. Everybody makes uric acid. In his teaching, the trouble starts when insulin is high and the kidneys stop clearing it.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 1286The problem is if you have insulin resistance, a lot of people cannot flush out at the kidney level their uric acid.
That ties the whole picture together for him. Juice is a fast hit of sugar. Sugar drives insulin up. High insulin, over time, is insulin resistance, and insulin resistance is what he says keeps uric acid from leaving the body. So prune juice works against you twice: more fructose going in, and more insulin holding uric acid back.
The same reasoning sits behind his take on breakfast cereal, covered in are Cheerios bad for gout.
What to drink instead
His list is short and it does not include juice of any kind.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 1643God didn't want you to drink fruit. He wanted you to eat it. What a difference when you eat fruit compared to drinking it. Don't drink it. Drink water, drink coffee.
On coffee he went further for gout specifically, with one condition.
Dr. Martin, The Doctor Is In, Episode 1643And by the way, for gout, one of the best things you can do is coffee, but don't put sugar in it.
In the same episode he told people with gout to hydrate with water, because uric acid leaves the body through the kidneys. Put together, his day for someone with gout looks like this: water through the day, coffee with no sugar, fruit eaten rather than drunk and kept small, and no juice. Prune juice included. For the rest of what he thinks on sugar, insulin and the foods around them, start at what Dr. Martin thinks.
Common questions
Is prune juice bad for gout?
Dr. Martin tells people with gout to stop drinking juices of any kind, which includes prune juice, because uric acid is a by-product of fructose.
Is prune juice high in purines?
Prunes are low in purines, but Dr. Martin puts fructose, not purines, first when it comes to uric acid.
Is unsweetened prune juice OK for gout?
Not in his view. He says uric acid comes from fructose whether it is from a grape or a soda, so natural fruit sugar counts too.
Can I eat prunes if I have gout?
He has not addressed prunes and gout directly. He calls prunes very sweet, counts all fruit toward sugar for gout, and favors a few berries over other fruit.
What should I drink if I have gout?
Water and coffee, with no sugar in the coffee. He says coffee is one of the best things you can do for gout.
Start with insulin
Dr. Martin ties gout to insulin resistance. Blood Sugar Support Formula is the clinic's daily formula for healthy blood sugar.
Shop Blood Sugar Support Formula
60-day money-back guarantee.